How Do Wine Ratings and Reviews Work: A Wine Lover’s Guide

How Do Wine Ratings and Reviews Work: A Wine Lover’s Guide

ByCristal G, WSET3 Advanced, Wine & Spirits Hours Last uncorked on

You find yourself standing in the wine aisle, a sea of labels swirling before your eyes. Cabernet, Pinot Noir, Malbec – how do you choose? Price can be a guide, but then you notice those little scores on the bottles. 90 points, 92 points… What do they mean? How do wine ratings and reviews work, and, more importantly, can they help you pick a good bottle?

Choosing wine can feel like learning a new language. The good news is wine ratings and reviews exist to help decode this language and potentially save you from a disappointing bottle. While they shouldn’t dictate your choices, they can give you a starting point.

Behind the Scores: Uncorking the Rating System

You’ve probably seen those numbers alongside words like “outstanding” or “classic.” That’s the 100-point system, a popular method of rating wines. Wine Spectator, a prominent name in the industry, uses this system. While other scales exist, like the 20-point system, we’ll stick with the 100-point system for now.

Think of this system as a report card for your Cabernet Sauvignon. The higher the score, the better the wine *should* be, based on criteria such as:

  • Appearance (color, clarity).
  • Aroma.
  • Taste.
  • Balance (acidity, sweetness, tannins).
  • Complexity (layered flavors).
  • Finish (how long flavors linger).

You might wonder, “How are these scores determined?” It usually comes down to a group of trained tasters such as seasoned critics, sommeliers, or expert judges at wine competitions. These pros go through wine-tasting rituals to arrive at a score.

Blind Tasting: Unveiling a Wine’s True Identity

No, it’s not wine-tasting in the dark. A blind tasting removes the preconceived notions that a fancy label or hefty price tag can create. Blacked-out bottles, neutral glasses, and pure sensory perception help keep the focus solely on the wine.

This method is essential for fair evaluation. Removing bias associated with price, reputation, or region allows a true assessment of the wine’s qualities. Studies have proven the effectiveness of this method in achieving unbiased results.

The Wine Judging Panel: Not Your Average Wine Club

Wine judging panels often comprise individuals immersed in wines – certified sommeliers, experienced winemakers, and respected wine critics. These experts can tell if your Sauvignon Blanc has hints of gooseberry or if your Pinot Noir has earthy notes.

These experts sniff, swirl, sip (and spit often to avoid wine overload). They meticulously consider every nuance, scoring the wine based on established criteria.

Reading Between the Lines: What Wine Reviews Tell Us

Wine ratings offer a numerical representation of a wine’s quality. They’re objective, quick to grasp, and relatively consistent. Reviews, however, delve deeper, using words to describe a wine.

Wine reviews give you a glimpse into the wine’s personality – the “why” behind the numbers. They provide insights into the flavor profile, such as whether a Sauvignon Blanc is light and crisp or bold and full-bodied.

Wine Critics: The Voices Behind the Vine

Like many culinary experiences, the world of wine has guiding lights known as wine critics. Two renowned critics who have dedicated their lives to wine are Jancis Robinson, a UK-based Master of Wine and author, and Robert Parker, an American wine critic whose palate influences many.

Jancis Robinson uses a 20-point system and Robert Parker uses the 100-point system, each offering unique insights. Their opinions on wines carry significant weight in the industry and can influence the perception and even pricing of certain wines.

Reputable wine publications, like Wine Spectator and Wine Enthusiast, have teams that taste and rate thousands of wines yearly. Wine & Spirits magazine also utilizes a panel and a unique methodology to rate wines, demonstrating the collaborative efforts in the industry to ensure consistent and quality reviews.

Wine Blogs and Online Platforms: Your Digital Sommelier

The internet has given a voice to countless wine enthusiasts who have become bloggers and online reviewers. One such platform is CellarTracker. This community-driven platform allows anyone to log, rate, and review wines, providing valuable insights for fellow enthusiasts.

The Power of Ratings and Reviews: Why Do They Matter?

You’ve read those tasting notes and decoded the critics’ metaphors. Now, what can you do with all this knowledge about wine ratings?

Finding Your Wine Tribe: Tastes Like…More, Please.

Discovering shared taste preferences in wine can be exciting. Wine ratings and reviews can help you connect with like-minded individuals who appreciate similar flavor profiles and styles.

Engaging with others with a shared passion for the same wines enhances the enjoyment of exploring new bottles. Online forums, tasting groups, and social media platforms provide forums where you can share your preferences and discover new favorites.

Value for Your Buck: Getting the Best Bang for Your Wine Budget

A higher price doesn’t always mean a better bottle. Sometimes, that 90-point, $20 bottle might be just as enjoyable as a 95-point bottle that breaks the bank.

Ratings and reviews from diverse sources can help you make informed choices when buying wine. If you have a good understanding of how much different types of wine should cost, you can find hidden gems at very reasonable prices. This allows you to explore wines from different regions with confidence.

You might even consider exploring restaurants recognized for their wine selections, like those awarded by the Wine Spectator Restaurant Awards. For example, the Kuda Villingili Resort in the Maldives earned the 2024 Wine Spectator Award of Excellence for its outstanding wine program.

Imagine facing a massive wine list at a fancy restaurant. Familiarity with highly-rated regions or producers can make you feel more confident. This knowledge helps you make informed decisions instead of blindly choosing the most expensive option.

Understanding wine ratings empowers you to communicate your preferences effectively with sommeliers. They can then recommend wines that align with your taste, enhancing your dining experience.

Beyond Personal Preference: How Do Wine Ratings and Reviews Work for Broader Use?

Wine ratings and reviews do more than assist individuals. They also influence market trends, pricing structures, and production decisions within the industry.

Sommeliers and wine buyers rely on ratings and reviews to curate wine lists and make purchasing decisions. Positive reviews can significantly impact a wine’s popularity and sales, especially for emerging wineries or lesser-known regions.

Data reports such as those from Impact Databank Reports, analyze consumer behavior based on wine ratings. This data provides insights into market trends and helps forecast future demand.

Publications like MarketWatch Magazine and Shanken News Daily utilize this data to report on the wine industry’s financial performance, highlighting the impact of ratings on sales and consumer preferences.

Conclusion

How do wine ratings and reviews work? They act as guides, not dictators. Hopefully, this explanation demystifies those little numbers on the bottles. Trust your palate, explore new wines, experiment, and, most importantly, enjoy the journey.

Whether you prefer a crisp Sauvignon Blanc, a bold Cabernet Sauvignon, or a fruity Pinot Noir, there’s a world of wines to discover. Remember, the best wine is ultimately the one you enjoy the most. So, go forth and choose wisely.

Similar Posts